Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra
I will always have the utmost disdain for so-called "progressive" orgs like this one that have weaponized the false specter of "hindutva" to attack diaspora Hindus.
BUT, well-meaning diaspora Hindus are not doing themselves any favors by maintaining links with India-based orgs like the RSS. This is not because, as these progressive orgs insist, the RSS is "extremist" or whatever, but simply because their clumsy attempts to shape Hindu politics in the diaspora are an impediment to us charting our own path.
The RSS chief will no doubt give the crowd the succor they crave by praising their ability to achieve great success in America without losing their "culture," and the attendees-- many of whom are recent immigrants anxious to find their political and cultural footing-- will briefly enjoy the illusion of power.
But it will amount to nothing. The speech will traffic in the idiom of the uncle at the function who insists that our religion is great and ancient, our culture is the best, and yet looks on befuddled as their own American-born children stray further and further away from their "roots." it will betray a total lack of self-awareness and understanding of the particular challenges we face.
But to our detriment, the first-generation attendees will leave even more reassured in their cultural and political myopia, and the second generation (the few that are paying attention at all) will look upon the whole thing as an awkward and embarrassing spectacle. Whatever the RSS's achievements in India, they have nothing to offer us, and the sooner the diaspora understands that our fate is on our hands alone, the better off we will be.
https://x.com/vjgtweets/status/2092396632767885405
That's not what I am advocating. But productive ties are only possible when each side is firmly established in their own perspectives and values. That's not possible when India-based orgs impose their particular understanding of Hindu tradition on to the diaspora, without any consideration of our particular challenges. In any case, this is what they have been doing, and the result is an abject failure.
https://x.com/vjgtweets/status/2092700244559716840
Thank you @avatans for the (rare) thoughtful response:
You say that my argument "precludes the RSS (and its affiliates) from having any legitimate role in diaspora discourse before the conversation has even commenced."
I'm not sure what you. mean here by "legitimate role." These orgs are free to propagate their ideas in the diaspora, as they have been doing so for decades. Their lack of relevance is in fact evidence of their clumsiness, and reflects their total ignorance about the socio-political dynamics of American society. Which is why I think orgs rooted in American society have nothing to gain by affiliating with them.
Next, regarding civilizational continuity. Here I think you elide the actual core point by simply assuming that civilizational continuity requires that the diaspora retain a connection to India. You carelessly through out comparisons to the Jews, Chinese, and Armenians, but never ask yourself whether these comparisons actually work. Are Hindus an ethnic community like the Armenians, Han Chinese, or Jews? No. Are they a "religious" community? I've argued this isn't the case either, since "Hinduism" is not a religion. Do Hindus have a historical sense of "peoplehood" that is even close to comparable with that of the Jews? Also no.I agree that Hindus share a civilizational heritage, but I see this heritage as universal in character, and don't believe continuity requires preserving ties to a particular nation, culture, etc.
On the cause of detachment, here too you misdiagnose the situation. American-born Hindus are alienated from India because, well, they are American. Acculturation is natural and inevitable. Since you brought up the comparison with the Jewish community, it is notable that the history of Jewish denominationalism in America is inextricably linked with this process of acculturation. The emergence of Conservative Judaism, e.g., was a direct response to the alienation of the children of Eastern European immigrants from the orthodox congregations established by their parents. By placing the blame on "longstanding embarrassment" by the second generation, you are shifting the blame, rather than introspecting about the failures of the first gen mode of transmission. I'm not saying this about you personally, but my sense is that is that a lot of first gen immigrants are triggered by this reality, because they are paranoid about losing touch with their roots. Well, I hate to break it to them, but the die has been cast in that regard.
On your final point, what favorable outcomes are you talking about? From my vantage point, all I see is abject failure. For the diaspora to chart its own course, it must be free of ideological and cultural constraints imposed on it by organizations that are fundamentally Indian in their orientation. The second gen has been decades being lectured about their "deracination" and the importance of "culture." To what end? Dialogue is only possible when each party approaches it on their own terms. Articulating those terms for ourselves requires that the diaspora put these orgs at a healthy distance.
https://x.com/vjgtweets/status/2092696886448898421
I think you nailed it. I think for many immigrants who are unclear about what Hindu religiosity means outside of India, the preservation of Indian culture is used as a proxy. This is exacerbated by a sort of ingrained conservatism that is natural to all immigrant communities
https://x.com/vjgtweets/status/2092709110261411933
Archives | At its core, the Hindu supremacist movement, like alt-right movements around the world, is hyper-masculine. Persecution, like all social injustices, falls disproportionately on women; Muslim and Dalit women are doubly victimised. There is now mounting evidence of a robust symbiosis between patriarchy and autocracy. The auctioning of Muslim women—journalists, activists and students who have been vocal critics of the ruling regime—was a case study in how the two evils mutually reinforce each other.
Read Vidya Krishnan's (@VidyaKrishnan) essay from May 2022, Hyper-femininity as resistance to Hindu supremacy: caravanmagazine.in/gender/hyper-f…
https://x.com/thecaravanindia/status/2092635554894774457
Buddhism quietly transformed Western psychology. MBSR, ACT, DBT, MBCT. These are the "third wave" of cognitive behavioral therapies, and every one of them has Buddhist contemplative practice built into its structure. Some of the therapists using these methods have no idea they're teaching something a monk would recognize. x.com/melhpine/stat u…
https://x.com/melhpine/status/2092597935791911039
[PDF] AN ALGEBRA OF CASTE IN THE UP ELECTIONS 2017
historical consciousness into the dominant upper caste Hindu consciousness
proved to have worked in favour of BJP. The role of RSS and Sangh Parivar has …
[PDF] Inclusive Dimension of Divisive Tools of Caste & Religion: Electoral Politics of Uttar Pradesh
Hindus as one identity irrespective of their caste. This debate was more pronounced
in Uttar Pradesh, manifesting as the SP/BSP, rooted in caste politics, and the BJP …
[PDF] The Secular Concept and Recent Controversy with Regard to Retention or Deletion of this Concept from the Preamble of the Constitution: An Overview
dominant spiritual heritage of India — just like in England where the Anglican
Church is the official Church of England and the king is the defender of faith but …
[PDF] Inverted Eurocentrism: The Consumption of Decolonization in the Global North and a Radical Decolonization Agenda
Eurocentrism and decolonization have come to be associated primarily with identity
and location rather than with capitalism and political economy. This article argues …
From Kautilya to Modi: Continuity and Transformation of Indian Statecraft
https://doi.org/10.1080/
The Question of Integrity in Affect in Group
claims, is inspired by many problematic positions. Truschke offers an important
critique of Hindutva and is a contributor to the (freely available) online Hindutva …
[HTML] Time to “Decolonize” Affect? aka The Question of Integrity in Affect in Group Relations
problematic positions. Truschke offers an important critique of Hindutva and is a
contributor to the (freely available) online Hindutva … drawn to problematic Hindutva-inflected …
[HTML] Dismantling the Myth of “Islamo-Wokeism” and Reclaiming a Shared Critical Inheritance
and Islam Colluded to Kill Critical Thinking,” published by Anglican Mainstream on
14 August 2026, takes as its occasion three genuine controversies at the University …
[PDF] Archiving Tragedies
majoritarian politics of Hindutva. Various states around the world have invested in
disaster sites (for instance, the Remains of Reactor 4 at Chernobyl) and conflict …
[PDF] Re-exploring Psychodynamics and Trauma in “Train to Pakistan, Ice Candy-Man, Tamas and Midnight's Children”
largest mass migrations and humanitarian crises in history, marked by extensive
violence and profound psychological trauma. This research aims to re-examine the …
[HTML] Beyond the Battlefield of Belief: Dismantling the Culture of Religious Combat
philosophy, a Kerala reform tradition, and contemporary experimental psychology
converge—from four independent starting points—on the same practical conclusion …
[PDF] Beyond State Solutions: Confronting the Contradictions in Hate Studies
its reliance on state mechanisms as primary solutions to hate despite overwhelming
evidence of state complicity in perpetuating systems of inequality and harm. Drawing …
HINDU EXTREMISM
Hindutva ideology. This exclusionary nationalist ideology, … Hindutva extremists
have promoted this argument online. A January 2024 tweet by a Hindutva account …
VIOLENT EXTREMISM IN THE DIGITAL AGE
21st century, transforming our societies and revolutionising many aspects of daily life.
As these technologies have become more powerful and sophisticated, the misuse of …
No comments:
Post a Comment